BLOG Navigating Flooring Choices for Restorative Renovations: Tips for Historical Homes Mar 09, 2025

Restoring a historical home is a rewarding journey, offering a unique opportunity to breathe new life into an architectural gem that’s rich with stories and charm. One of the most impactful aspects of any renovation is the selection of flooring, a decision that requires careful consideration. At Finnegan Flooring, we understand the challenges and excitement involved in preserving the authentic character while making practical choices for modern living. Here’s a guide to help you navigate the flooring options for your historical home renovation.

Understanding the Era and Style

When embarking on a renovation of a historical property, one of the first steps is to understand the home’s original architectural style and era. This knowledge is crucial because it dictates the types of materials and finishes that would have been used historically. For example, oak hardwood floors were popular in Victorian homes, whereas wide-plank pine might have been the choice in colonial structures. Rich walnut or mahogany could be seen in more opulent Georgian homes. Keeping this in mind will help guide your selection toward options that maintain historical integrity.

Evaluating Condition and Needs

Before deciding on any new flooring installation, it’s vital to evaluate the current condition of what’s beneath your feet. If the original flooring is intact, restoration could be a viable option. Sanding and refinishing hardwood might reveal a beautiful layer beneath years of wear. However, if the floors have suffered too much damage, replacing them with similar historically appropriate materials might be necessary. At Finnegan Flooring, we offer professional assessments to help you make an informed decision.

Material Matters

Choosing the right material is essential not only for aesthetics but also for functionality and durability. Hardwood is a timeless choice that complements most historical homes while offering longevity. However, if moisture is an issue, especially in basements or bathrooms, opting for materials like engineered wood or luxury vinyl that mimic the appearance of wood might be more practical. Tile can also be a beautiful and durable option, especially in spaces like kitchens or entryways where foot traffic is high.

Balancing Tradition with Modern Needs

When renovating a historical home, it’s often necessary to find a balance between traditional aesthetics and modern needs. Incorporating underfloor heating can be an attractive option in cold climates to provide comfort without sacrificing historical appearance. Finnegan Flooring specializes in solutions that integrate modern technology with historical designs, ensuring you get the best of both worlds.

Color and Finish

The finish of the flooring can significantly influence the overall feel of your home. Consider the role of light and color within your space. While dark stained floors can add warmth and a classic feel, lighter colored stains might help small spaces appear bigger. Matte and satin finishes often work better than high gloss in historical homes, retaining a natural appearance while being practical for daily living.

Concluding Tips

Choosing flooring for a historical renovation is more than simply picking a material; it involves respecting the past while designing for the future. Ensure your choices are informed and reflective of the home’s original character while also meeting your lifestyle needs. Whether you are restoring original floors or selecting new materials, remember to consider the historical context.

At Finnegan Flooring, we are dedicated to helping our customers achieve beautiful, authentic results in every project. Contact us today to discuss how we can help bring your vision of a timeless restoration to life.